One question to ask of anything that wants your time, your words or your trust. We tried it on chanio first. It did not get off lightly.
From the ground up
A product does what it is paid for.
Not what its makers hope, and not what its front page says. The makers move on. The front page gets rewritten. What it is paid for stays put.
SoBefore you trust a thing, ask what it is paid for.
An incentive turns perverse when the product gains as you lose.
A thing paid by the hour will find you more hours. A thing paid for what it knows about you will be very curious about you. A thing paid when you cannot leave will make leaving difficult, and be polite about it.
SoNobody has to be a villain. The number does the work.
Good intentions do not outlast the number.
Most people who build software mean well. Then there is a target, and the target turns out to be easier to hit with a reminder, a badge and a small red dot.
SoLook at what is built in. A promise is the first thing a target eats.
The right incentive pays only when you are better off, and lets you leave with everything.
Then the easy way to do well is to be useful. Nobody has to be watched, including the people who built it.
SoThat is the whole test. The rest of this page is the test being used.
Seven places to look
Each is a way of being paid that goes up as you do worse. Under each: what chanio does, and a page where you can check it.
Paid in your time.
What it looks likeStreaks. Reminders. A feed with no bottom. A number that goes down if you take a day off, which is an odd thing to do to someone you like.
On chanioNo streak, no reminder, no feed. The mirror is finished when you close the tab. If a thing you wrote about goes quiet, it counts the days and tells you the number when you next open it. It does not come and find you. What the mirror does when something goes quiet
Paid when you are not looking.
What it looks likeA renewal that is switched on for you. A price that goes up a little each year, by a letter built to go unread. A setting that moved in an update. The plan is that you have better things to do.
On chanioOn a Mac, chanio works overnight, which is exactly when nobody is looking. So what it did is in a morning summary, written on your own machine. Only the questions you kept go to a bigger AI, each with the few passages it needs, on your own key, under a daily limit you set. With no key, they are packed for you to paste. What happens overnight
Paid when you cannot leave.
What it looks likeYour record, kept in a shape only it can read. An export that exists, technically, and arrives as a puzzle.
On chanioOn a Mac your memory is plain files in a folder. In a browser, one button saves everything the mirror holds as one file. Both open without chanio. What is kept, and where
Paid in what it knows about you.
What it looks likeAn account before you have seen anything. Questions it has no use for. A box for your email, for your convenience.
On chanioNo account, and no page here asks for an email address. Nothing you type in the mirror is sent anywhere. What this site collects
Paid each time you ask.
What it looks likeAnswers that need a follow-up. A helper that would rather you asked again than remembered.
On chaniochanio answers with your own sentences and the days you wrote them, so next time you may not need to ask. When a bigger model would do better, it tells you. How it answers
Paid when you feel good about it.
What it looks likePraise. A score. A badge for turning up. An AI that agrees with you a little too warmly.
On chanioNo grade, no praise and no opinion of you. The mirror counts days and quotes your own lines. It has never called anyone a rock star, and it is not going to start. Why a count, and never a verdict
Paid in big numbers.
What it looks likeCounts rounded up. A chart that only goes one way. The word “millions”, used loosely.
On chanioThe numbers on this site are counted each night from a Mac’s own logs and published as they come, the small ones included. Tonight’s numbers
Where chanio comes off worst
A test that only its author passes is an advertisement. These are the places it catches us.
Nothing is for sale here.
So nobody who uses chanio pays for it, and a thing that asks for no money is easy to keep honest. This test has not been tried on chanio under pressure. That is the weakest part of this page, and you should weigh it.
The site counts page views, and a few taps.
A view of each page, and a few taps such as Copy on the install line. Each is a daily total, with no cookie and no row per visit, published on the stats page. On a Mac, sending weekly counts is off unless you turn it on. A count is still a number, and numbers pull. So the mirror counts nothing at all: chanio cannot tell what you did there, or whether you came back.
There is one nudge.
On a phone, the notebook suggests adding it to your Home Screen. That is a nudge and we are not going to call it anything else. It is shown once.
One page talks to an online AI.
The page at /join/ sends what you type there to an online AI so it can answer, and tells you so on the page. Nothing from it is kept.
The same test, for what you build
If you are turning something you keep coming back to into work, you are about to decide what you are paid for. It is the most important design decision you will make, and it is usually made by accident, late, by whoever sets up the payment page.
Decide it on purpose. Five questions, in your own voice:
Who is better off because of this, and how would they know?
What exactly am I paid for: that, or their time, their attention, or their not being able to leave?
When I do better, do they do better, the same, or worse?
If they stop, what does it cost them, and what do they keep?
Which number will I be tempted to grow that does them no good?
If the answer to the third is “worse”, no mission statement will rescue it. Change what you are paid for while it is still cheap to change.
This test will not make anything succeed. It tells you which way a thing will pull once it is busy.
The same questions, for whichever AI you use
Fill in the one line, then paste it. There is nothing of yours in it until you add it, and chanio does not send it.
I am working out how to be paid for something I care about. Here it is, in my own words:
[say what it is, in a line or two]
Reason from first principles, from what I tell you only. Ask me these one at a time, and wait for my answer to each:
- Who is better off because of this, and how would they know?
- What exactly am I paid for: that, or their time, their attention, or their not being able to leave?
- When I do better, do they do better, the same, or worse?
- If they stop, what does it cost them, and what do they keep?
- Which number will I be tempted to grow that does them no good?
Then tell me any place where the way I am paid would pull against the people I mean to help, and one way of being paid that pays only when they are better off.
Do not tell me whether to do it. Do not flatter me. Do not add facts I did not give you.
Start with what you keep coming back to
The test needs a thing to test. Your mirror shows what you came back to, counted in days, from your own lines. Type the question there and take it to an AI with your own words beside it.